RBI Moves Supreme Court to Review Verdict on YES Bank's ₹8,415 Crore AT-1 Bond Write-Off
The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has approached the Supreme Court with a review petition challenging the apex court's ruling that overturned the controversial write-down of YES Bank's Additional Tier-1 (AT-1) bonds worth ₹8,415 crore. The central bank's legal challenge comes just days after YES Bank filed its own petition under Article 137 of the Constitution of India seeking reconsideration of the apex court's verdict.
The dispute stems from the court's judgment upholding a January 2023 Bombay High Court decision. The bench, comprising Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih, had held that the RBI-appointed administrator lacked the statutory power to write down the perpetual bonds during the March 2020 rescue package. The court also questioned the central bank's oversight in the matter and rebuked YES Bank for offloading high-risk subordinated debt instruments to retail investors in contravention of the RBI's Master Circular guidelines.
Key Developments in the AT-1 Bond Dispute
- Regulatory Stand: The RBI's review petition aims to defend its restructuring authority and the emergency powers exercised during the 2020 rescue orchestrated alongside a consortium led by the State Bank of India.
- Bondholders' Stand: Axis Trustee Services, acting on behalf of 400 to 450 institutional and individual bondholders, had called on YES Bank to reinstate the bonds immediately, cautioning of potential contempt proceedings for non-compliance.
- Capital Impact: YES Bank previously disclosed that reinstating the principal of the ₹8,415 crore AT-1 bonds would hit its Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) ratio by approximately 250 basis points on a pro forma basis, although its Tier 1 capital ratio would remain at 14%.
The instruments under review comprise two separate series: a ₹3,000 crore tranche carrying a 9.5% coupon issued in December 2016, and a ₹5,415 crore tranche with a 9% coupon issued in October 2017. Following the Supreme Court's verdict directing the restoration of the debt instruments, the lender also noted that it retains coupon discretion under the original bond memoranda, creating further uncertainty over pending interest arrears.
For the broader Indian banking and fixed-income ecosystem, the joint resistance from both YES Bank and the banking regulator is closely tracked. A final decision on the review petitions will carry profound ramifications for the pricing of future AT-1 issuances across public and private sector lenders, clarifying the legal sanctity of write-down clauses during distress-driven bank rescues in India.